Guides

Answer the new-client call that comes in while you're in court

The phone is off in the courtroom and a potential new client is working down a list. How to take the call, collect names for the conflict check and book the consultation, by hand or automated.

What it costs you

You're in district court for a calendar call, phone off in your jacket pocket, waiting for your matter to be reached. Your paralegal stepped out for lunch. Back at the office the phone rings out and goes to voicemail.

The caller was served with divorce papers last night. She found three names in a search and yours came first. She doesn't leave a message, because what she has to say isn't something she wants to tell a recording, so she hangs up and dials the second name on her list. Somebody there answers and books her for Thursday.

Other mornings it's a son whose mother died on Sunday and who has no idea where the will is, or a man who was rear-ended on I-40 and is calling from the urgent care parking lot. Each of them wants to know the call landed somewhere and that someone will call back.

By the time the judge takes a recess and you turn your phone on, you have a missed call from a number you don't know and no voicemail. You call back at 12:40. She has already booked with the other firm.

Then there's the call that does get answered, by whoever happens to be near the phone, and goes wrong the other way. The caller is upset and starts telling the whole story: names, dates, what her husband said, what she did about it. Nobody stops her. If the husband called the firm first, the firm may now be holding information about his case that it cannot unhear.

A good first call is short. Who's calling, who's on the other side, what kind of matter, and how to reach them. Everything else waits for the consultation.

Do it yourself this week

  1. Decide who answers while you're in court. Write it down for every day of the week: the paralegal, a colleague down the hall, an answering service, or forwarding to a cell phone someone carries. A phone that rings out on court mornings is a decision nobody made.

  2. Write a short intake script and keep it by every phone. Caller's name and best number, the name of the other party or parties, the kind of matter in a few words, and how they'd like to be reached. Add one line asking the caller to hold the details until the lawyer speaks with them. Whoever answers doesn't have to improvise, and the call stays short.

  3. Run the names through your conflict check before anyone calls back. Hand the caller's name and the other party's name to whoever runs conflicts at your firm, and get the answer before a consultation is booked or anyone talks about the matter.

  4. Write down what counts as urgent at your firm. Your list, in your words: a caller who says they are in danger, a child who wasn't returned after a visit, an existing client with a hearing in the morning. Next to each, write what the person answering should do, whether that means pulling you out of a meeting, calling a colleague, or telling someone in danger to hang up and call 911. Keep the page where whoever answers can read it.

  5. Record a greeting for court days. Say the firm's name, that the lawyers are in court this morning, when calls get returned, and what to leave: a name, a number and the other party's name. A caller who hears when you'll call back has a reason to wait instead of dialing the next name.

  6. Text back every missed call you can't return within the hour. Save one message in your phone: "This is [firm]. We're in court this morning and will call you back by [time]. Reply with your name and the best time to reach you, and please don't send details of your situation by text." Send it at the first break.

  7. Keep an intake log. One row per call: date and time, name, number, other party, kind of matter, who called back and when, whether the conflict check cleared, and whether a consultation was booked or declined. If your practice management software has an intake or call log, use that instead. On Friday afternoon you can see which calls never got a callback.

Where doing it by hand breaks down

Every step above assumes someone is free to pick up. In a small office, court mornings take the lawyer and often the paralegal too, and whoever is left at the front desk is also handling a walk-in and a client on the other line. The script sits by the phone while the phone rings out.

Answering services help, and plenty of firms use one. Most take a message and pass it along, so the callback still waits for the next recess, and a service that doesn't know law offices can let a caller talk at length about the case.

The missed-call text works when you remember it, between a ruling and the next matter called. The log fills in on quiet days and goes blank on busy ones, which are the days the calls come.

How we'd automate it

Concierge, our AI phone receptionist, answers your firm's own number whenever you can't: in a hearing, on a calendar call, after hours. It answers in your firm's name and tells the caller at the start that it's an AI assistant.

Then it does what your intake script does. It takes the caller's name and number, the name of the other party and the kind of matter, and asks the caller to save the details for the lawyer. Depending on your rules, it books a consultation or sends you the names by text and email so you can run conflicts before anyone calls back. When a call matches your firm's list of what's urgent, it puts the caller through to the person you named. If your rules tell it to, it tells a caller who says they are in danger to hang up and call 911. Your rules decide, not the software.

What it won't do matters as much. Concierge doesn't give legal advice and won't answer "do I have a case?" or "what's it worth?" It doesn't run your conflict check, it doesn't decide whether the firm takes the matter, and nobody becomes a client on a call with it. Court dates stay on your docket.

Your practice management software may already handle intake forms or text reminders, and Concierge works alongside it. A booked consultation reaches you by text and email in a form that takes seconds to enter; it doesn't land in your system by itself. You keep your own number and forward calls to it, all of them or only the ones you miss. You write the greeting, choose the questions and set the urgent list. It's built in accounts your firm owns. We're not a law firm and we don't give legal advice; the lawyer decides.

The caller from last night hears back with a time on it, and you get to stay in the courtroom.

Talk it through

Book a free discovery call and we'll walk through how calls reach your office now, who answers on court days, and where they wait. You leave with a written plan whether you set it up yourself or have us build it. To see what unanswered calls might be costing you, try the free missed-call calculator.

Written by Oak City Intelligence's AI writer and reviewed before publication.