Guides

Follow up on the consultation before the engagement letter goes stale

Follow up the unsigned engagement letter by email or text until the answer is yes or no, and get the non-engagement letter out when it's no.

What it costs you

The consultation went well. She asked good questions about her will and what she wants to leave her son, you quoted a flat fee for the package, and she said she'd watch for the engagement letter. You emailed it that afternoon with a friendly note.

On day fourteen it's still unsigned. You meant to follow up the next week, but that was the week of trial prep in another matter, and by the time you came up for air her name was buried in your inbox under everything that arrived since.

From there it goes one of two ways. She hired someone else, a lawyer who called her the morning after their consultation and answered the question she had been too polite to ask you. Or, worse, she thinks you're working on it. She told her son the plan is being drawn up. Months later something happens, and the family calls to ask why nothing was ever signed.

Family law and personal injury consultations go quiet the same way. The father in a custody dispute who needed to talk to his sister about the fee. The woman hurt in a wreck who wanted to think it over the weekend. Each consultation cost you an hour and a conflict check, and each one now sits in a folder nobody owns.

Malpractice carriers have warned for years that claims from people you never thought of as clients are a real risk, and their answer is the non-engagement letter: a short written note, sent when it's clear the person isn't going ahead or when you've waited on them long enough, saying the firm does not represent them. Agreeing with that takes a second. The hard part is the moment to send it, which arrives when nobody is looking at the file.

Do it yourself this week

  1. List every consultation without a signed engagement letter. Go back through your calendar and sent email for the past couple of months. Give each one a row: name, kind of matter, date of the consultation, the fee you quoted, the date the letter went out, the next follow-up date, and a status of signed, declined, quiet, or non-engagement letter sent.

  2. Send the engagement letter the same day, with the next step in plain words. Tell the potential new client what to sign, how to send it back, and that the firm opens the file once the signed letter arrives. If your practice management software offers e-signature, use it, so signing takes a tap instead of a printer and a scanner.

  3. Put three follow-up dates in when the letter goes out. A short note the next business day asking whether anything in the letter needs explaining, another a week later, and a last, plain one asking for a yes or a no. Write the dates on the row the day you send the letter, not later.

  4. Write the follow-ups once, in your own voice. Keep them short, specific to the matter and free of pressure, and save them as templates in your email or your practice management software. Send them only to people who came to you first, by email or text, and stop the first time someone says no or asks you to stop.

  5. Answer the real question. When a reply comes back with a question about the fee, the scope or the timing, it goes to the lawyer who held the consultation, the same day if possible. A follow-up that ignores the question someone asked reads like a form letter.

  6. Set your limit for silence. Decide how long the firm waits after the last follow-up before it treats silence as a no, and write it down where everyone can see it. When a row reaches the limit, it moves to the non-engagement list.

  7. Send the non-engagement letter and file a copy. Draft your firm's standard letter once so it's ready, or start from a sample your malpractice carrier provides if it offers one. The lawyer reviews and signs each letter. Put a copy in the potential new client's file, note the date on the row, and close it.

Where doing it by hand breaks down

Follow-up dates come due in the same weeks the work does. A trial, a mediation and two signing appointments land together, and the next-day note goes out on day five, the week-later note never goes out, and the row says "quiet" until someone opens the sheet again.

Non-engagement letters slip worst, because nothing prompts them. A signed letter announces itself by arriving; silence makes no sound at all. The person who never answered is on nobody's mind, and the limit you set passes without anyone noticing.

Practice management and intake software can show you which matters are still waiting on a signature, and some of it sends reminders. Somebody still has to notice the reply that came in at 10 at night, hand the question to the right lawyer, and remember that a no starts a different task.

How we'd automate it

Lead Follow-up puts every unsigned engagement letter on a follow-up schedule the day it goes out, in your wording and in your name. Each note goes by email or text on the dates you choose, and only to people who contacted the firm first. It stops the moment someone says no or asks it to stop, and it never phones anyone.

You approve the templates before anything goes out, and replies come back to you. Someone ready to sign gets pointed back to the letter. A question about the fee, the scope or the matter goes to the lawyer who held the consultation, because the follow-up doesn't answer it.

Paperwork Chasing picks up when the answer is no, or when silence passes the limit you set. It reminds the lawyer that a non-engagement letter needs to go, and keeps reminding until the lawyer marks it sent. The lawyer writes it, signs it and sends it; we don't.

Your intake or practice management software may already send some of these reminders. If it does, we leave that part alone and fill the gaps around it. Everything runs alongside the software you already use, built in accounts your firm owns: your email and calendar on Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, and your phone number. We're not a law firm and we don't give legal advice, and the lawyer decides who becomes a client.

The engagement letter gets its second ask and its third, and the ones that end in no get their letter too.

Talk it through

Book a free discovery call and bring the list of consultations that haven't signed, or just tell us where they live. We'll show you where they stall, and you leave with a written plan whether or not you hire us to build it.

Written by Oak City Intelligence's AI writer and reviewed before publication.